MENU
FORTRESS OF SOLITUDE
No Result
View All Result
TRENDING:
  • DC Universe
  • Marvel
  • Movies
  • TV
  • Star Wars
  • Sci-Fi
  • Horror
FORTRESS
No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • DC
  • Marvel
  • Superman
  • Batman
  • Star Wars
  • Horror
  • Sci-Fi
  • Netflix
Home
Movies
Movie Features

James Gunn Has a Serious Problem After Supergirl’s Box Office Disaster. Only Batman Can Save It.

Supergirl lost its opening weekend to Toy Story 5, earned a B- CinemaScore and bombed internationally. Now James Gunn's entire DC plan is under the microscope.

Jarrod SaundersbyJarrod Saunders
June 29, 2026
Milly Alcock as Supergirl in Supergirl (2026)

Image Credit: DC Studios / Warner Bros. Pictures

Share to Facebook
Share on X
Share on Reddit
Google Preferred Source Google News Preferred Source

James Gunn’s DCU has been off to a rough start. After moving away from the DCEU, which was mostly influenced by Zack Snyder’s trilogy (Man of Steel, Batman v Superman and Justice League), Superman was meant to be a fresh start for the DC Universe under the watchful eye of CEO’s James Gunn and Peter Safran. But considering that Superman (2025) failed to reach the same heights as the first DCEU films, there were many who were already calling it a failure. So, Supergirl (2026) had a lot to prove. Unfortunately, after an awful launch at the box office this weekend, it could become one of the year’s biggest bombs. 

Supergirl is only the second live-action film in the DCU, and it was meant to prove that the franchise could fly without the Man of Steel holding its hand. Instead, Milly Alcock’s big-screen debut as Kara Zor-El has opened to a disappointing $38 million domestically and around $68 million worldwide, losing the weekend to Toy Story 5 (which stayed at no.1 for another weekend). That’s really not a good start for a film reportedly carrying a $170 million production budget.

And, unfortunately, the argument that the box office isn’t what it used to be a few years ago doesn’t work anymore because films like A24’s Backrooms and Obsession have proved that audiences are still showing up to the movies, with those titles pulling in millions across the globe.

So, for a studio trying to rebuild trust after The Flash, Shazam! Fury of the Gods, Blue Beetle, Aquaman and the Lost Kingdom and years of brand confusion, this is exactly the kind of result Gunn and Safran could not afford this early.

And, honestly, knowing the past, Supergirl was always going to be a risk. Superman’s cousin doesn’t have a good track record at the box office. The 1984 Supergirl movie, starring Helen Slater, was supposed to ride on the strength of the Christopher Reeve Superman films and expand the franchise. Instead, it became one of DC’s most infamous failures, a movie that seemed to scare studios away from female-led DC films for decades.

Milly Alcock DCU Supergirl Movie
Image Credit: DC Studios

Fortress of Solitude already warned that Milly Alcock was walking into a character with a complicated cinematic history. James Gunn and the filmmakers who worked on the project knew that history. Warner Bros. knew that history. And yet somehow, they decided that Supergirl was to become the second major theatrical pillar of the new DCU.

And the live-action failures are not because Supergirl is a bad character. Kara Zor-El is actually one of DC’s most interesting heroes. She has tragedy, rage, humour, cosmic scale and a completely different relationship with Earth than Clark Kent. But that is also the problem. She is a harder, stranger, more emotionally bruised character to sell to casual audiences than Superman, Batman or Wonder Woman – who are far more popular heroes.

James Gunn needed to lead the new DCU with certainty and guaranteed hits. Batman and Wonder Woman would have provided that. Before asking general audiences to care about Supergirl, Clayface, The Authority, Swamp Thing or Booster Gold, Gunn probably needed to lock in the Trinity first. Those are DC’s most popular characters after all. Everything else works better when those three chairs are occupied.

Milly Alcock Supergirl Krypto
Image Credit: DC Studios

Marvel did not build the MCU by leading with Moon Knight and Echo. It started with Iron Man, Captain America, Thor and Hulk – the Avengers. Then the studio earned the right to go weirder – even though that has proven to be a hit or miss too. DC has spent more than a decade proving that audiences do not automatically follow the logo. They follow characters they understand, actors they recognise in the role, and stories that feel essential.

Supergirl feels optional – even its story doesn’t feel critical to the DCU story Gunn is currently telling. Audiences probably believe they can skip this one and go straight into Man of Tomorrow without missing anything. And they’re probably right. Superman felt like the beginning of something. Supergirl feels like a side quest off-planet.

The audience reaction did not help either. A B− CinemaScore is not toxic, but for a superhero movie that needs word of mouth, it is dangerous. It suggests the opening-night crowd — the people most likely to be excited — left the cinema divided. Add mixed critical reception and the usual online arguments about superhero fatigue, gender, politics and franchise direction, and suddenly the movie is facing an uphill battle.

Peter Safran has already tried to calm the waters, saying Supergirl did not meet box office expectations but remains part of a broader long-term DC Studios strategy. That is the public answer he has to give. Nobody expects a studio executive to come out after opening weekend and say, “Yes, we are panicking and preparing to rethink our entire strategy now.” But behind the scenes, this has to be the conversations they are having.

Because if Supergirl cannot launch strongly, then what happens when DC gets to even riskier projects? What happens to Clayface? What happens to The Authority? What happens when the DCU asks audiences to invest in characters they barely know while Batman and Wonder Woman are still mostly out of the picture?

That is why the timing of the new Batman rumours is so interesting.

batman dcu
Image Credit: HBO Max

Reports have started circulating that Tom Brittney, who previously said to have tested for Superman before David Corenswet landed the role, could be in line to play the DCU’s Batman. Nothing has been officially confirmed by James Gunn or DC Studios, so this should be treated carefully. But the rumor is all over social media in the last few days and it actually makes sense in one very obvious way: after Supergirl, DC may need Batman now more than ever. It’s the one character who works at the box office over and over again. It’s the less risky project too. You cannot sidebench Batman forever. That is not how you rebuild DC.

Supergirl’s box office collapse does not mean the DCU is dead. That would be dramatic, even for comic book Twitter. But it does mean Gunn needs to rethink his plans moving forward. The audience has sent a message: they are not showing up for the DCU just because it says “from DC Studios” on the poster.

Supergirl may still find defenders. It may even build a following later. Plenty of comic book movies have been bruised in cinemas and reappraised later. But the box office does not grade on future cult status. It grades on urgency. Right now, audiences did not feel Supergirl was urgent enough.

The new DCU was supposed to be a clean break from the confusion. But clearly it wasn’t.

Now James Gunn may have no choice but to bring Batman and Wonder Woman in much sooner than planned.

Tags: Batman Movies, TV Shows & ComicsDC UniverseJames GunnMilly AlcockSupergirlSuperhero MoviesSupermanWonder Woman
Share
Tweet
Share

About the Author: Jarrod Saunders

Jarrod Saunders is the Editor in Chief of Fortress of Solitude. An entertainment journalist and filmmaker with 18+ years of professional criticism. IMDb-credited director. Published by The Direct, Nicki Swift, and Thought Catalog. Watches 500+ films a year.

Related Posts

Anthony-Mackie-Desert-Warrior
Movie Features

Anthony Mackie’s $150M Epic Opened to $488K. One Thing Explains Why Hollywood Keeps Casting Him

byTito Pernalete
November 17, 2026
Michael-J-White-Spawn
Movie Features

“We Want a Michael J. White Type”: Michael Jai White Responded to the Call and Still Didn’t Get Blade

bySergio Pereira
November 15, 2026
James-Gunn
Movie News

“Fired Me on Valentine’s Day”: The DC Actor Who Isn’t Mourning James Gunn and Peter Safran’s Exit

bySergio Pereira
November 14, 2026
henry cavill best superman
Movie News

“Never Say Never”: Henry Cavill Opens the Door to Returning as Superman After Gunn and Safran Exit DC Studios

bySergio Pereira
November 12, 2026
dceu dcu james gunn crossover
Movie Features

James Gunn’s DCU Is Over, and It Left DC in Worse Shape Than Zack Snyder Did

bySergio Pereira
November 11, 2026

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

TRENDING

sylvester stallone arnold schwarzenegger movies
Movie Lists

Seth Rogen Says Predator Alone Beats Everything Stallone Ever Made — Stallone’s 5 Best Movies vs. Schwarzenegger’s Say It’s Not That Simple

Friday the 13th Part VIII Jason Takes Manhattan
Movie Features

Jason Voorhees Racked Up 150+ Kills, but Kane Hodder Refused to Kick a Dog in Friday the 13th Part VIII

dceu dcu james gunn crossover
Movie Features

James Gunn’s DCU Is Over, and It Left DC in Worse Shape Than Zack Snyder Did

The 55 Most Powerful Marvel Characters Of All-Time, Ranked
Comics

Who Is the Strongest Marvel Character? 55 Beings Ranked by Power Level, From Professor X to One Above All

sylvester-stallone-steven-seagal
Movie Features

“He Wasn’t Invited to That Party”: Sylvester Stallone Says Steven Seagal Was Begging to Join The Expendables

Stallone-Rambo-III
Movie Features

“The Kid’s Got to Die”: Rambo III’s Director Says Stallone Wanted His 9-Year-Old Co-Star Killed Off After the Boy Corrected His Lines

My Name is Earl Jaime Pressly Joy Turner
TV Features

Jaime Pressly Has Been Calling Her Own Shots Since She Emancipated Herself at 15 — Now the My Name Is Earl Star Is on OnlyFans and Producing Her Own Movie

gone-baby-gone-morgan-freeman
Movie Features

Morgan Freeman Called Out Ben Affleck on the Gone Baby Gone Movie Set, According to a Co-Star Who Watched It Happen

Antonio Banderas as Ahmad ibn Fadlan drawing a sword in the rain in The 13th Warrior (1999)
Movie Lists

The 10 Best Viking Movies, Ranked: The 13th Warrior Bombed Hard, but It’s Better Than You Remember

renee o connor gabrielle xena warrior princess
TV Features

Xena’s Gabrielle Took a Break From TV to Raise a Family. 25 Years After the Finale, Here’s What Renee O’Connor Is Doing Now

Fortress of Solitude

© 2026 Fortress of Solitude, a division of Fortress Entertainment PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved.

More about Fortress of Solitude

  • About Us
  • Contact Fortress of Solitude
  • Work With Us
  • Advertise with Us
  • Sign Up For Our Newsletter
  • Publishing Principles
  • Ethics Policy
  • Terms of Service
  • Ownership
  • Privacy Policy & Site Disclaimer

Follow Us

No Result
View All Result
SUBSCRIBE
  • MOVIES
    • Movie Features
    • Movie Lists
    • Movie News
    • Movie Reviews
  • TV
    • TV Features
    • TV Lists
    • TV News
    • TV Series Reviews
  • COMICS
    • Comic Features
    • Comic Lists
  • GAMING
    • Gaming Features
    • Gaming Lists
    • Gaming News
    • Game Reviews
  • TECH
    • Tech Features
    • Tech News
    • Tech Reviews
  • INTERVIEWS
  • ABOUT US
    • About Us
    • Contact Us
    • Advertise With Us
    • Ownership
    • Work With Us
  • WIN

© 2026 Fortress of Solitude, a division of Fortress Entertainment PTY LTD. All Rights Reserved.