Hollywood loves patterns. Actors hit a hot streak, ride it for five years, then vanish into airport thrillers. You’ve seen it happen. What’s stranger are the outliers, the performers who never quite got that one film. Not even by accident. Across decades, studios kept calling, budgets kept growing, and audiences kept asking why. From the 1980s to the 2010s, these 10 actors built careers stacked with misfires, flops, and baffling choices. No classics. Not even cult saves.
10. Hulk Hogan
Before Dave Bautista and Dwayne Johnson made Hollywood take wrestlers seriously, Hulk Hogan aimed for movie stardom. You probably remember the ambition more than the hits. Outside a sharp Rocky III cameo, critics shrugged. Studios kept calling, audiences drifted. The ring swagger didn’t always fit scripts, timing, or tone.
9. Kevin James
Kevin James, now 60, hits pay dirt once in a while, then trips over it. Monster House in 2006 showed you what he could do with just a voice. Then came Sandy Wexler in 2017 and Home Team in 2022, both loud, flat, and forgettable.
8. Pauly Shore
Don’t let the nostalgic charm of Encino Man deceive you: Pauly Shore’s career is more of a comedy of errors than a Greatest Hits collection, with stinkers like For Keeps and The Bogus Witch Project standing out as true atrocities.
7. Jamie Kennedy
His most memorable role was playing the lead in Son of the Mask. Honestly, that’s all that needs to be said.
6. Jennifer Love Hewitt
Jennifer Love Hewitt was 18 when I Know What You Did Last Summer hit cinemas in 1997 and owned pop culture for five loud minutes. That slasher wave couldn’t sink her, but the follow-up choices did. You watched the credits roll on flat releases, waiting for a rebound that never landed. Then came Delgo in 2008, a misfire people remember as trivia.
5. Jessica Alba
The first Sin City felt like a comeback for Jessica Alba. You saw it in 2005, noir grit, swagger back. Then the stumble. Alba kept choosing wrong turns, and by 2014’s Sin City: A Dame to Kill For, the buzz had cooled. The sequel landed with a thud, not a revival. If you were rooting for Alba at 33, this hurt. But has Jessica Alba actually ever made a good movie?
4. Steven Seagal
Under Siege demonstrated that Seagal could become an icon like Stallone or Schwarzenegger, but movies like Out for a Kill and China Salesman proved that he was better suited as a legendary internet meme. Or as Russia’s special envoy to the U.S., for some reason.
3. Kirk Cameron
After Growing Pains turned Cameron into a teen fixture in the late 1980s, he swerved hard into Hollywood projects that baffled even patient fans. You watched the fame fade as faith-based movies piled up, each one drifting further from anything resembling “entertainment”. Saving Christmas, released in 2014, still lands as the punchline. It played like a sermon with a budget, not a movie night.
2. Carrot Top (Scott Thompson)
Seeing the rising popularity of fellow stand-up comedians like Jerry Seinfeld and Dave Chappelle in the 90s, Carrot Top was driven to bring his prop-based comedy to Hollywood. The result is a string of box office bombs that are better left forgotten. The less said about Chairman of the Board, the better.
1. Taylor Lautner
Taylor Lautner keeps dodging legendary disasters. His filmography shows discipline. Not one outright stinker, and somehow not one winner either. Rotten Tomatoes backs it up. Zero “Fresh” ratings. That’s wild consistency. Lautner stays parked in direct-to-video purgatory.
RELATED: Actors Who Can’t Act (But Somehow Keep Getting Cast)
