Darren Aronofsky nearly made a Batman movie, and it wasn’t going to be your typical cape-and-gadgets James Bond take on the character either. In 2000, Warner Bros. was still recovering from Joel Schumacher’s Batman & Robin disaster and the studio was desperate to reboot the Caped Crusader for a new generation of comic book kids. Aronofsky, fresh off a streak of award-winning films, and comic book legend Frank Miller, were ready to adapt Batman: Year One for the big screen. What could go wrong?
Aronofsky admits he wasn’t fully committed to the superhero path. On the Happy Sad Confused podcast, he explained, “I was really focused on The Fountain, I never really took that seriously. I wanted to make Fountain, that’s where I was at.”
The script he co-wrote with Miller was dark, gritty, and rated R, a “down and dirty, duct tape kind of movie” that wouldn’t sell Batmobiles or Happy Meals. Aronofsky even envisioned Joaquin Phoenix as Bruce Wayne, while the studio pushed for Freddie Prinze Jr., a clear sign their priorities didn’t align. “Uh oh, we’re making two different films here,” he told Empire.
Frank Miller backed him up, saying Aronofsky was the more radical member of the team. Miller recalled, “I said ‘Darren, would you be willing to be faithful to the comics?’ and he was ready to rip the eyes out of them.”
Their version of Bruce Wayne wasn’t the inherited-rich-guy playboy everyone knows. Instead, Wayne rejects his fortune, lives on the streets, learns to cook, studies martial arts around the world, and returns to Gotham ready to face corruption head-on. Meanwhile, Jim Gordon starts out wary of this mysterious vigilante, only to eventually team up with him to clean up the city.
Warner Bros. wasn’t ready. At the time, an R-rated Batman was a hard sell. Aronofsky told Variety, “A rated-R superhero movie was probably 10 to 15 years out of whack with the reality of the business then.” The studio’s reaction ranged from horror to polite confusion—they wanted a safer, merchandise-friendly Batman, not a gritty, street-level crusader. The creative mismatch was unsurprising, and by 2002, Aronofsky had left the project.
The fallout left a gap that Christopher Nolan would later fill with Batman Begins. Nolan’s version leaned on the same Year One material but tempered the darkness enough to win the studio’s trust while redefining the modern superhero movie.
Aronofsky’s film might have been ahead of its time. Today, R-rated superhero movies like Deadpool & Wolverine, Joker and Logan have found audiences, but back then, they were uncharted territory.
Aronofsky also briefly toyed with other DC projects, including Watchmen and Man of Steel, but nothing stuck. Maybe someday the right project will come along and we’ll finally get a Darren Aronofsky DC or Batman project. But right now, it’s not happening.
RELATED: Tyler Hoechlin Wants To Play Batman In James Gunn’s DCU
Discussion about this post